Beyond ‘guilty’ or ‘not guilty’ – could a range of verdict options be more just? | Aeon Videos
Published by Reblogs - Credits in Posts,
Beyond ‘guilty’ or ‘not guilty’ – could a range of verdict options be more just?
Many countries have a binary justice system that sorts defendants into two very broad categories: ‘guilty’ and ‘not guilty’. Those deemed ‘not guilty’ are often left with the stigma of a criminal record, even when the accused was overwhelmingly proven to have done nothing wrong. Meanwhile, another defendant might also be labelled ‘not guilty’, despite substantial evidence of guilt, if a single juror had some lingering doubts. And in some countries, such as the United States, the system incentivises agreements that pressure defendants to plead guilty to crimes regardless of their actual guilt. In this video from Wireless Philosophy, Barry Lam, an associate professor of philosophy at Vassar College, discusses alternatives to the prevailing two-verdict system that might more accurately reflect degrees of uncertainty – as well as some of their potential pitfalls.
Video by Wireless Philosophy
Aeon is not-for-profit and free for everyone
Make a donationGet Aeon straight to your inbox
Join our newslettervideo /
Food and drink
From set-up to close, a day at the farmers market is a whirlwind sensory feast
10 minutes
video /
Dance and theatre
From calluses to burnt shoes, the elegance of ballet is built from the ground up
4 minutes
video /
Gender and identity
Timothée built his identity around his absent father. What happens when they meet?
17 minutes
video /
Work
Living out of a truck, Maikhuu finds promise and peril on Mongolia’s ‘coal highway’
25 minutes
video /
Metaphysics
Is the question ‘Why is there something instead of nothing?’ even worth asking?
9 minutes
video /
Work
Catch those idle moments of connection between coworkers on a smoke break
10 minutes
video /
Logic and probability
Is it more likely you’re a person with a past, or an ephemeral brain in a void?
6 minutes
video /
Ageing and death
‘It’s not beautiful, but it’s interesting’ – an ageing nude model surveys her body
4 minutes
video /
Ethics
An animator wonders: can you ever depict someone without making them a caricature?
10 minutes